Paul Davies wrote:
> Hi Sreeni,
>
> Thank you for your comments, which I have processed.
>
> My responses are inline.
>
>> Page 3:
>> The GlassFish v3 Technology Preview 2 Application Server product
>> greatly simplifies the task of
>> creating and administering web applications.
>>
>> The application server does more than webapplications, should we
>> emphasize on web applications ?
> DECLINE: I discussed this comment with Abhijit. He agreed that as the
> focus of *TP2* is the web tier, the emphasis in these release notes
> should be on web applications.
>
>> Page 5:
>> Feedback Submittal form
>> (http://java.sun.com/docs/forms/J2EE14SubmittalForm.html)
>>
>> Pl. check the link also check other links for accuracy.
> ACCEPT - In fact the link to the feedback submittal form has been
> removed as it is inappropriate to the TP2 release milestone.
>
>> Page 6:
>> ¦ Glassfish Wiki: Plan for GlassFish v3
>> (http://wiki.glassfish.java.net/Wiki.jsp?page=PlanForGlassFishV3)
>>
>> Instead of calling 'Plan for GlassFish V3', we could say 'GlassFish
>> V3 Wiki', otherwise it sounds like the wiki is specific to Planning
>> and there may be other page which talks about V3 itself.
> ACCEPT - When I created this link, the focus of this page was GlassFish
> v3 planning. Now that the focus has moved away from planning towards
> GlassFish v3 generally, I have changed the text of the link.
>
>> Page 7:
>> GlassFish v3 Technology Preview 2 Application Server is a server for
>> the development and deployment of web applications.
>>
>> As I mentioned earlier, V3 TP2 can also accomodate ejb applications,
>> so specifying web applications may narrow the scope. Pl. check with
>> Jerome.
> DECLINE: For the same reasons that I declined your comment on page 3.
>
>> Page 8:
>> Scripting Language Support.
>>
>> Do we want to talk about other scripting languages also or just ruby.
>> Refer to the following link
>> http://wiki.glassfish.java.net/Wiki.jsp?page=ContainersConfiguration
> DECLINE: From the TP2 feature list at
> http://wiki.glassfish.java.net/Wiki.jsp?page=GlassFishV3TP2Content ,
> only JRuby is listed under Scripting Support.
>
>> Page 10:
>> Disk Space
>>
>> GlassFish V3 TP2 doesn't need as much memory as needed by GF V2. 35
>> MB Seems high, check with QA.
> DECLINE: I could not get a reliable figure. My own experiments showed
> that 35 MB was more than enough, but not by much.
>
>> Remove SDK since it is not applicable.
> ACCEPT
>
>>
>> Page 10:
>> TABLE 2–2 Default PortAssignments for GlassFish v3 Technology Preview
>> 2Application Server
>>
>> As I know, we use 8080 for admin as well as applications. Do we need
>> 8181 and 4848 ?
>>
>> Request Kedar/Anissa to confirm.
> DISCUSS: I have removed reference to port 8080, but without any
> indication about what to do about port 8181, I have left that in.
>>
>> Page 12:
>> Using the Bundled Java DB Database
>>
>> I see a lot of discussion on Java DB including starting in network
>> mode etc. Shouldn't all this be part of Java DB doc. ?
>>
>> Can we point instead ?
> DECLINE: The information still seems to be relevant, and the pointers
> to the Admin Guide provide more detail.
I thought the purpose of RN is to provide latest info which could not
have made into the doc.
>
> Regards,