I am really surprised to see that nobody answered your question. After 18 months from your post I verified the same problems using LEFT JOIN FETCH with toplink essentials and it seems to me a big performance issue. I will stop using toplink. How can toplink essentials be the reference implementation of JPA ?
[Message sent by forum member 'arreumb' (arreumb)]
http://forums.java.net/jive/thread.jspa?messageID=294458