dev@glassfish.java.net

Re: patch review request for issue #9896

From: Dies Koper <diesk_at_fast.au.fujitsu.com>
Date: Tue, 10 Nov 2009 09:27:28 +1100

Hi Marina,

I'll start now updating my workspace, re-apply the patches, run the QL
and commit the ones I received the OK for.
I suppose that'll take a few hours (I usually have to clean the maven
cache and filling it up takes a while).

Feel free to make your changes in the meantime, I can resolve the
conflicts if there are any.

Regards,
Dies


Marina Vatkina wrote:
> Hi Dies,
>
> persistence/cmp is OK.
>
> ejb needs a separate bug to remove unused messages, but if it's easier
> to fix first, go ahead.
>
> thanks,
> -marina
>
> Dies Koper wrote:
>> Hi Hong, Marina, Jerome, Jan, Byron, Satish, Ken, Jagadish, Sahoo,
>>
>> I've attached another patch (msg-single-quotes-local.patch) with a fix
>> for the issues in LocalStrings.properties and Bundle.properties; see:
>> https://glassfish.dev.java.net/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=9896
>>
>> This is in addition to the msg-single-quotes.patch I asked a review
>> for two days ago.
>>
>> - deployment/dol (Hong)
>> - persistence/cmp (Marina?)
>> - core/kernel (Jerome?)
>> - web (Jan)
>> - admin (Byron)
>> - jms (Satish)
>> - ejb (Ken S.)
>> - connectors (Jagadish)
>> - verifier (Sahoo?)
>>
>> Could you give me the OK to commit them?
>>
>> Thanks,
>> Dies
>>
>>
>> Dies Koper wrote:
>>
>>> Hi Jan, Byron, Shin-Wai, admin/monitor owner,
>>>
>>> I have attached a patch to issue #9896 (issue #4 in my previous
>>> list), please review.
>>>
>>> admin/monitor (?):
>>> admin\monitor\src\main\java\org\glassfish\admin\monitor\LogStrings.properties
>>>
>>>
>>> common-util (Byron?):
>>> common\common-util\src\main\java\com\sun\logging\enterprise\system\tools\launcher\LogStrings.properties
>>>
>>> common\common-util\src\main\java\com\sun\logging\enterprise\system\tools\admin\LogStrings.properties
>>>
>>> common\common-util\src\main\java\com\sun\logging\enterprise\system\core\selfmanagement\LogStrings.properties
>>>
>>>
>>> security (Shin-Wai?):
>>> security\core\src\main\resources\com\sun\logging\enterprise\system\core\security\LogStrings.properties
>>>
>>>
>>> web (Jan):
>>> web\war-util\src\main\resources\com\sun\logging\enterprise\system\container\web\LogStrings.properties
>>>
>>>
>>> This patch only covers the issues in LogStrings.properties.
>>> I hope to send out a patch review request for the remaining message
>>> files by Monday or Tuesday. If you think you might be too busy to
>>> review a patch then, would you consider authorizing someone (Carla,
>>> for instance, or even just me) to review it so I can commit it before
>>> HCF?
>>> Note that the only changes I'm making here are for the single quotes
>>> issue.
>>>
>>> Thanks,
>>> Dies
>>>
>>>
>>> Dies Koper wrote:
>>>
>>>> Hi,
>>>>
>>>> We had several threads about the messages: that they need message IDs,
>>>> diag info and (not much discussed) be externalized for localization.
>>>> Sekhar has even prepared a tool to help.
>>>>
>>>> Since then I think everybody has been too busy to actually do the work.
>>>>
>>>> I'd like to help out where I can, and already sent out a patch to
>>>> Shalini directly for jdbc, but felt we still have different opinions
>>>> about what to do. I'd like to move the discussion here to explain my
>>>> intentions so that all the module owners for whom I might prepare
>>>> similar patches are in agreement with it.
>>>>
>>>> For now, I'd like to fix the following issues:
>>>>
>>>> 1. Messages with no ID
>>>>
>>>> 2. Typos (just the obvious ones, I'm not a professional proofreader)
>>>>
>>>> 3. Message ID (layout) issues (such as space in "RAR 7014")
>>>>
>>>> 4. Single apostrophes in messages with arguments (see issue #9896)
>>