Hi Rebecca,
I could not access the wiki page. My question was, should such changes
fall in realm of upgrade tool or not?
Thanks,
Mitesh
Rebecca Searls wrote:
> Mitesh,
>
> These are exactly the types of incompatibility issues that we want
> to avoid,
> when making product improvements. These changes break the
> compatibility
> requirements agreed upon by the ARCH and articulated in this document
> http://wiki.glassfish.java.net/Wiki.jsppage=UpgradeCompatibilityRequirements
>
>
>
> Apps that are deployed in a prior product version that is being
> upgraded to V3
> must be able to run in the new product without requiring manual
> edits by the user.
> This means V3 CMP and JPA must implement some way to handle this
> without user intervention.
> The old style settings do not have to be supported for new apps
> deployed into V3.
> Those apps can be required to use the new settings.
>
>
>
>
>
> Mitesh Meswani wrote:
>> .... I could think of following changes that might be of interest to
>> upgrade tool.
>>
>> 1. We have a backward incompatible change in CMP that I am not sure
>> whether falls in upgrade tool's realm. We have decided to remove
>> deprecated element persistence-manager-factory-resource from
>> domain.xml. If a user's app was using the element from its
>> sun-ejb-jar.xml, it needs to be changed to point to corresponding
>> jdbc-resource element. Do you think upgrade tool could/should help
>> such app?
>>
>> 2. We have also changed the default JPA provider from TopLink
>> Essentials to EclipseLink. User's persistence.xml if referring to
>> toplink.* properties would need to be changed to use eclipselink.*
>> properties. Again, do you think upgrade tool could/should help such app?
>>
>> Apart from above changes I can not think of any backward incompatible
>> change from persistence.
>>
>> Thanks,
>> Mitesh
>>
>> Rebecca Searls wrote:
>>> Attached you will find the presentation slides for today.
>>>
>>>
>>> On 07/14/09 16:24, Rebecca Searls wrote:
>>>>
>>>> Please join me Thur Jul 16 from 12:00-1:00 PT to learn about
>>>> the API
>>>> each module *must* implement to support domain upgrades in V3.
>>>>
>>>> V3's design model requires a new way of performing domain
>>>> upgrades.
>>>> Modules are required to implement a new service to support
>>>> domain
>>>> upgrade functionality. This TOI will present the API that must
>>>> be implemented, discuss how to test your implementations, and
>>>> answer your questions.
>>>>
>>>> Slides will be available day of the TOI.
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> Date: Thur Jul 16
>>>> Time: 12:00-1:00 PT
>>>> Toll-free ( US) 866-545-5227
>>>> International number 215-446-3648
>>>> Passcode: 5933769
>>>
>>
>> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>>
>> Subject:
>> Removing deprecated element persistence-manager-factory-resource
>> From:
>> Mitesh Meswani <mitesh.meswani_at_sun.com>
>> Date:
>> Tue, 10 Mar 2009 16:05:31 -0700
>> To:
>> Ian Evans <Ian.Evans_at_Sun.COM>, Sreenivas Munnangi
>> <Sreenivas.Munnangi_at_Sun.COM>, June Parks <June.Parks_at_Sun.COM>, Sherry
>> Shen <Sherry.Shen_at_Sun.COM>, Ming Zhang <Ming.Zhang_at_Sun.COM>, Raja
>> Perumal <Raja.Perumal_at_Sun.COM>, Elena Asarina <Elena.Asarina_at_Sun.COM>
>>
>> To:
>> Ian Evans <Ian.Evans_at_Sun.COM>, Sreenivas Munnangi
>> <Sreenivas.Munnangi_at_Sun.COM>, June Parks <June.Parks_at_Sun.COM>, Sherry
>> Shen <Sherry.Shen_at_Sun.COM>, Ming Zhang <Ming.Zhang_at_Sun.COM>, Raja
>> Perumal <Raja.Perumal_at_Sun.COM>, Elena Asarina <Elena.Asarina_at_Sun.COM>
>> CC:
>> Jerome Dochez <Jerome.Dochez_at_Sun.COM>, Abhijit Kumar
>> <Abhijit.Kumar_at_Sun.COM>
>>
>>
>> Hi,
>>
>> The element persistence-manager-factory-resource was deprecated since
>> appserver 9.0
>> (http://docs.sun.com/app/docs/doc/819-3661/abhdz?l=en&a=view
>> <http://docs.sun.com/app/docs/doc/819-3661/abhdz?l=en&a=view>). This
>> element is used by cmp beans to point to jdbc-resource-jndi name. We
>> are planning to stop supporting this element in V3. This will avoid
>> extra work for CMP, CLI and admin GUI.
>>
>> *What is the impact for you? *
>> SQE. Samples, CTS, Tutorial::
>> If you were using this resource from your sun-ejb-jar.xml, you will
>> need to update it to point to the jdbc-resource directly instead of
>> indirecting through persistence-manager-factory-resource
>>
>> Docs, Tutorial:
>> We will need to remove reference to it from our documentation.
>> Possibly add to a section that lists known incompatibility with
>> previous versions.
>>
>> Can you please let us know by end of day Friday March 13 if you see
>> any issues with the decision. If you are on 'To' list of this mail,
>> you are a stack holder. Please point to alternate person if you
>> believe that is wrong.
>>
>> Thanks,
>> Marina and Mitesh
>>
>